Nazareth - Church of the Annunciation

Vertical tabs

Source of knowledge
Literary sources
Epigraphy
Archaeological remains
Surveyed site
Surveyors: 
NameDate
Quaresmius
1617-26
Tobler
1868
Hardy/Goudard
1905
Chevalier
1906
Baldi
1935
Excavated site
Excavators: 
NameDate
Vlamink
1892
Viaud
1910
Bagatti
1955-1960
History: 
The site marking the event of the Annunciation was already a shrine for the cult of the Virgin Mary in the late Roman and early Byzantine period. Remains of this shrine, including architectural elements, graffiti and painted plaster, were discovered beneath the monastery and church that were excavated by Bagatti. The shrine was dismantled and its fragments were used as fill for the foundations when the church and monastery were constructed, apparently in the early fifth century. The structure stood until the twelfth century when it was dismantled to make way for a large and elaborate Crusader church. The Crusader church was destroyed in the second half of the thirteenth century by the Malmeluk Sultan, Baybars. In the eighteenth century a Franciscan church and monastery were constructed on the site. A fourth church was constructed on the site, along with a Franciscan convent and seminary, in the twentieth century, after the eighteenth century structure was torn down.
Discussion: 
The monastery of the Church of the Annunciation is similar to the monasteries attached to important churches in Jerusalem- the monasteries of the Spudaioi. The monks' function was probably to provide the necessary services for visiting pilgrims. Therefore, the church itself, a pilgrims' destination, cannot be regarded as a monastic church. This is the type of monastery identified by Hirschfeld as monasteries "attached to memorial churches" (Hirschfeld 1992: 55-56). Although his reference was to Judean Desert monasteries located on the pilgrimage routes and not to urban or village monasteries, we can regard the latter monasteries as belonging to this type including the one in Nazareth.
State of certainty: 
Archaeologically and Literarily definitive
Architectural evolution
General outline: 
The church and its adjacent monastery were constructed in the early fifth century CE. The structure forms one integral unit. It was constructed over fill consisting of architectural members and other remains of the earlier structure named by Bagatti "pre-Byzantine" and dating to the fourth-early fifth century.
Dating material: 

The paving in the monastery was dated by Bagatti to post 427 CE, based on the circles in the mosaic pavement which did not contain crosses in keeping with the imperial decree of 427 CE.

Phase date
Century: 
5th c.
Within century: 
First half
Iconoclastic evidence
Iconoclastic evidence: 
No
General outline: 
A small monastery apparently continued to exist at least up to the 9th century, attested in the Commemoratorium de Casis dei in 808 CE. It is not known if the monastery continued to function right up to the twelfth century when the church was rebuilt by the Crusaders.
Dating material: 

Literary source.

Phase date
Century: 
9th c.
General outline: 
There is no evidence to its having been abandoned or otherwise. It is even possible that a small community of monks was still on the premises or nearby when the Crusaders overtook the region.
Phase date
Century: 
Unknown
Post Arab conquest history: 
Still in use